David Crosby on Johnny Rogan |
Posted on Thu, Sep 9 1999 at 8:44 a.m. PDT by
David T.
<[email protected]>
|
From Tim:
I was
just visiting a site about the Byrds called ByrdWatcher. It
has a long interview with David Crosby. In the
interview, he talks about Johnny Rogan in terms that
are very... familiar. Seems like Morrissey isn't the only
one to question the man's veracity.
Excerpt:
I Have Seen
That Movie, And It Wasn't Like That
BW: There is a lot of detail about Michael's last days that
I hadn't ever heard before in the new version of Johnny
Rogan's book...
DC: Rogan is not actually a very good source. Johnny
Rogan thinks he knows everything, and he speaks with
great authority, but he is repeatedly wrong. If you
sit down with that book, I can show you 24 mistakes in the
first 7 pages. He comes off as if he really knows
everything, and he is an opinionated little son of a
bitch, but he is continually misinformed. And I would like
to go on record as saying "Do not take Johnny
Rogan as an accurate source, because he damn well
isn't." He can't even spell names, let alone get facts
right.
BW: There's a funny interview where Chris Hillman runs into
him sometime after that book comes out and just gives him
the dickens. And Rogan recounts it, pretty much at his own
expense, somewhere. He basically got the bum's rush from
Hillman, and it's like a three paragraph interview.
DC: I'm not surprised. You know, Chris feels, I'm sure, very
much the same way I do. The guy is... you know, he comes off
opinionated as hell and acts like he really knows what the
hell he is talking about and he really damn well doesn't. If
he had expressed all of his misinformation as opinion, I
would have said, fine, he has a right to all the opinions he
wants. But he purports it to be the facts, and he is sadly
mistaken.
|
|
|
|
* item archived - comments / notes can no longer be added.
|
Comments / Notes
and that is exactly why I will never buy the book.
Corey <[email protected]>
- Fri, Sep 10, 1999 at 04:01:04 (PDT) | #1
well i received the severed alliance as a gift a while back and i read about half of it and then i was so disgusted with rogan that i never returned to finish it. i kept it cause it has a really cute picture of moz at his first communion.:)
adrien <[email protected]>
- Sat, Sep 11, 1999 at 12:14:24 (PDT) | #2
yes...I agree...I think I may just buy it to sit on the shelf, but never read it*l* That way I don't have to wonder what is true and what isn't
Corey <[email protected]>
- Sat, Sep 11, 1999 at 17:24:27 (PDT) | #3
This book has some glowing reviews on Amazon.com and I was very tempted to read it. From what I can put together it seems that the book is written in a psycoanalitic point of view. Right there and then I had doubts. For one thing Johnny Rogan isn't really qualified to do psycoanalysis. Plus how can someone give a good analysis when he doesn't even know Morrisey or other members of the band. But for the completist, I heard that it had some good obscure well dug info but that what it is only good for.
Junior
Hawaii - Mon, Sep 13, 1999 at 04:57:01 (PDT) | #4
|
* return to Morrissey-solo |